Ffxiv easiest classes

Machinist. ". The war with Dravania rages on, brutal and unrelenting. With no end in sight, the Holy See grows desperate. As her dragoons lay down their lives in defense of their home, Ishgard turns to technology to protect her sons and daughters. Great cannons and ballistas now line the city walls, plucking dragons from the sky.

Im not very good at MMO games usually, this was no exception, I picked White Mage and was shit at healing, got to level 52 and just gave up. The…Healers Easy- WHM Hard- SCH. Melee Easy- RPR Hard- MNK. Phys ranged Easy- DNC Hard- MCH. Casters Easy- SMN Hard- BLM. This is all my opinion but I would say black mage is probably the hardest in the game just because of how it plays and knowing fights helps it more than any other class. [deleted] • 2 yr. ago.Boss FATEs are nearly impossible to solo, except for ARR ones where you probably can cheese using BLU. If you are farming crystals for Anima Weapons (or FATEs lower than lvl 60 in general), BLU could be really good depending on the spells you have learned. If you have it, Blue Mage is king for FATES in earlier areas.Take your Leveling Roulette everyday. It's way too easy to get Esoterics to be honest. 5 Lore is laughably easy, and you can easily cap it in one week anyway. You can get 100 Esoterics every Void Ark run. IMO the exp you get from Leveling Roulette is more valuable than the Eso/Lore you can get from it.Marauder / Warrior (Tank) - Medium. Conjurer / White Mage (Healer) - Easy. Gladiator / Paladin - Easy. Arcanist / Summoner - Very easy. Lancer / Dragoon - Very easy. Source - Caetsu Chaiji Ch. Those are the classes that are in the game and how they are ranked up according to their difficulty. So if you are a beginner player and a ...In terms of most stuff to do as in rotations, timers, and utilities: Paladin is the hardest. It has 4 rotations and a bunch of mitigation. The most survivability tho. Dark Knight is the easiest. One rotation and a bunch of OGC you string in between. I'm God's son, son of man, and son of Marcus Garvey.

Hi, welcome to a beginner's job overview as of patch 4.5. The goal of this guide is to help you make an informed decision on what job (s) to play as you journey through FFXIV. Note that the game designers do keep the jobs very balanced by making frequent and minor adjustments, without drastically changing how they play.Prior to obtaining enough Poetics to purchase IL 130 gear, new players should complete their level 50 job quest to receive a coffer containing IL 90 armor . Alternatively, Basic- rarity crafted gear made with Heavensward materials was added as "catch-up gear." These can be bought HQ off the Market Board, giving IL 115, with Gil.Relatively low survivability when compared to other classes. Certain pets can draw unnecessary attention in dangerous areas. 5. Sage. The Sage, a healer job introduced in the Endwalker expansion, commands unique technology and magic. Pros: Strong healing capabilities, ensuring sustainability in solo fights.Every class is easy in PvP, they all get ~6 total skills to use outside of the general self heals etc. Just pick a class that looks interesting and learn how the skills work. Just picking a "simple" class isn't really a thing for PvP, and unless you're in high level ranked your choice won't matter nearly as much as knowing how to play.5. ScoobiusMaximus. • 2 yr. ago. Don't know what class is the best but I'm betting Warrior is near the top. They got a lot better with the Raw Intuition change since they have massively more self heal at level 70 than they used to. Reaper and new Summoner are probably also pretty good.No job in the game is as rigid and braindead as MCH. The other two aren't far behind in how simple they are of course. 2. Jays_Arravan. • 2 yr. ago. I feel MCH is the easiest ranged dps. No RNG, just the simple gameplay of press buttons to fill up bar to press buttons. 2. BrosefAmelion.Sage. Sage is the newest healer, introduced with the Endwalker expansion. It excels at staying on top of the situation with its plentiful mitigation and shielding and a steady flow of passive healing. Its signature mechanic is Kardia, automatically healing the designated ally when the Sage casts offensive spells.2 Goldsmith. While it may not seem that great on paper, Goldsmith is one of the most useful classes to level. They can craft precious jewelry that can be sold for high amounts of Gil and accessories with multiple Materia slots to maximize your DPS or healing for the hardest raids in the game. Not only will players bid for your time as a crafter ...

5. ScoobiusMaximus. • 2 yr. ago. Don't know what class is the best but I'm betting Warrior is near the top. They got a lot better with the Raw Intuition change since they have massively more self heal at level 70 than they used to. Reaper and new Summoner are probably also pretty good.I'd argue MNK is probably the easiest to do passable on, if only because you have basically your full combo kit from 50, and everything else is utility or a simple oGCD damage button. You spend a lot of time learning it and building that muscle memory as you level. It's definitely the most intimidating.Aug 10, 2022 ... This video will go over how to level your crafters from level 1 to 90 using Quick Synthesis, Collectables, Daily Quests, Custom Deliveries, ...The only more beginner-friendly class I can think of is gladiator. Technically, marauder can be better in the mid-term as it turns into the easiest tank over level 56, but before that, gladiator/paladin is more beginner-friendly. 1. Reply. SleepyFox2089.It has access to Brotherhood, which increases the party's damage by 5%. Monk is a challenging job to learn and master, but quite rewarding for players who enjoy a fast-paced, execution-heavy ...

How to replace shower cartridge moen.

Mar 21, 2023 ... ... ff14 #ffxiv # ... FFXIV Tier List - RATING JOBS BY HOW FUN THEY ARE! Alninio•25K views.Paladin and Warrior. Many people often go to the Conjurer/White Mage route, but other alternative jobs are just as noob-friendly. Take the Paladin and Warrior class (transforming into Gladiator and Marauder, respectively). These classes are elementary to get into and master skill-wise. Tanks, in general, tend to be more lenient with their players.The Summoner class is regarded as one of the easiest DPS classes to play in FFXIV due to its simple rotation. What is the easiest class to solo in Ffxiv? The Paladin class is the most well-rounded job for tackling the game's single-player content.Ya, it's odd that their stats don't match up with their lore (i'd think they'd have one of the highest dex for xaela at least) It's kinda hard to point them out to the STR-based melee classes since they sorta belong to existing ARR cities (e.g. DRK - religious enforcers from xenophobic ishgard , PLD - protectors of the immigrant-hating Ul'dah ), and Au Ra being new and unfamiliar to the land.Dark Knight is a job in Final Fantasy XIV, introduced in the first expansion pack, Final Fantasy XIV: Heavensward. Dark Knight requires no base class and begins at level 30, unlocked by completing the quest « Our End » offered by an Ishgardian Citizen at The Pillars (13, 8).

A community for fans of the critically acclaimed MMORPG Final Fantasy XIV, with an expanded free trial that includes the entirety of A Realm Reborn and the award-winning Heavensward and Stormblood expansions up to level 70 with no restrictions on playtime. ... Depends on the class. From easiest to hardest: CUL: dead easy, just level FSH and ...A community for fans of the critically acclaimed MMORPG Final Fantasy XIV, with an expanded free trial that includes the entirety of A Realm Reborn and the award-winning Heavensward and Stormblood expansions up to level 70 with no restrictions on playtime. FFXIV's latest expansion, Endwalker, is out now! Reaper is the easiest by far. Not only is its rotation brain dead because no enshroud or arcane circle, melee is the easiest job for uwu as you don't have to do any baits. Just follow the party. While MCH is easy, you need a whole other word for how automatic summoner is. It's the only DPS with no real fail state. BLU. Which class specifically does the most differs from each fight. But in generel if you want high numbers pick a Melee dps class. But at the end every dps class contributes pretty much the same dps to the group because of dmg buffs. The stronger buffs a class got the less damage it deals by itself and vice versa.RDM is incredibly strong for PotD. Group I ran with for my floor 200 clear was PLD (me), RDM, BRD, WHM. I took PLD over the other tanks at that time due to Shield Bash, which gives PLD a huge CC advantage the other tanks couldn't match (although mobs on later floors become immune to stun). As others have mentioned, though, experience matters a lot.for potd mch and rdm are the two best options. for hoh apparently gnb is best but war drk rdm mch and brd are also strong option. cdmike70. • 3 yr. ago. Machinest doesn't get much new to play with in HoH over Palace but it's probably still the best class for attempting to finish it solo.9. Natsuaeva. • 2 yr. ago. Reaper, Black Mage, Bard, Warrior, Scholar. If you're looking for easiest classes of each role then imo there's not much difference between tank difficulty, but; White Mage, Summoner, Dancer, Dragoon for each role, imo ^^. 4. for potd mch and rdm are the two best options. for hoh apparently gnb is best but war drk rdm mch and brd are also strong option. cdmike70. • 3 yr. ago. Machinest doesn't get much new to play with in HoH over Palace but it's probably still the best class for attempting to finish it solo. Best beginner-friendly ranged DPS (Archer) As FFXIV’s only Physical Ranged Class, Archer eventually becomes Bard, making it one of three Jobs in the Role.While Dancer may be the easier Job for ...Shopping for home decor can be a daunting task, especially when you’re not sure where to start. With so many options available, it can be difficult to know which stores offer the b...

The Diadem. The most commonly used method to level gatherers is the Diadem, a gathering-only zone that provides players with an easy way to level with little gear. The Diadem can be accessed through the Ishgardian Restoration. You can start the Diadem at level 10 on your gathering class, but it will first require you to be level 60 in …

2.BLM ( still a bit easy) 3.SMN ( you need some time to adjust to its playstyle, medium difficulty) Red Mage was only hard because I didn't know where to start, do PotD solo, and now I'm questioning what my favorite between BLM and RDM is. I would recommend a guide by Fevir on YouTube, explained it pretty well while I was studying the class.Without further ado, here is everything you need to know about the different FFXIV races from lore to height comparisons and everything in between. Here are all the FFXIV races: Hyur. Miqo'te ...PvP Power Score 89/100. 3. Red Mage. Bully enemy teams with debilitating status effects or swap to defense and support team healers! Red Mages are a hybrid caster-melee class that can swiftly transition between using spells and melee attacks to adapt to various scenarios and enemy lineups.Ya, it's odd that their stats don't match up with their lore (i'd think they'd have one of the highest dex for xaela at least) It's kinda hard to point them out to the STR-based melee classes since they sorta belong to existing ARR cities (e.g. DRK - religious enforcers from xenophobic ishgard , PLD - protectors of the immigrant-hating Ul'dah ), and Au Ra being new and unfamiliar to the land.His primary game beats are Pokémon Go, Destiny 2, Final Fantasy XIV, and any newly released title, and he finds it difficult to pull away from any Star Wars game. Gamepur Logo Putting the game in ...The [TOP 10] FF14 Best Solo Classes in 2023. Are you a fresh or experienced player in FF14? Do you ever feel like you want to explore on your own in the wild realm of Eorzea? With this article on GAMERS DECIDE, you'll find out about the best Classes you can roam around with on your own and win without a party! The [TOP 10] FF14 Best Solo ...In that case, out of the starting DPS classes Archer or conjurer would be the easiest to pick up. All of the non-expansion jobs are pretty intuitive and they ease you into how to use the different skills. But you won't have to worry about "mastering" your class until endgame and by then you should have a much better grasp on the game as a whole.Go to ffxiv. r/ffxiv. r/ffxiv. A community for fans of the critically acclaimed MMORPG Final Fantasy XIV, with an expanded free trial that includes the entirety of A Realm Reborn and the award-winning Heavensward and Stormblood expansions up to level 70 with no restrictions on playtime. FFXIV's latest expansion, Endwalker, is out now! White Mage is probably by far the easiest, NG+ exists. DNC and RDM are very easy on controller if you want DPS, WHM if you want healer. DRK or WAR if you want tank. You can do everything on controller with no problems. Just make sure you set up the Expanded Crossbar options and you should be good to choose whatever you like.

Ramona carniceria.

Goddess of the hearth crossword clue.

At the start of the game these are the base classes that are pretty simple and easy to use by the time you get to lvl 90. The rotations are straightforward/static and easy to learn. Later on you class upgrades to a job. Tank -Marauder/Warrior. Healer - Conjurer/White mage. Dps - Arcanist/Summoner, Lancer/Dragoon. Easiest Tank is WAR. Least amount of buttons, fairly straightforward rotation. PLD is very easy to learn as well, but is the hardest job to play at an optimal level. I find Gunbreaker super interesting from an aesthetic standpoint but my friends have warned me it's super hard to learn if you've never tanked before.... Healers - WHM easiest (can be boring because of its low CPM), AST hardest (actually enjoyable because of its busy-ness) Ranged DPS - MCH easiest (has an easy rotation with zero procs, and my ping isn't an issue), BRD hardest (has a rotation [through songs] and priority system with procs, and requires DoT uptime that other ranged DPS don't have).Dont play DPS, play tank. Tank has the smallest delta between low and high percentiles, and the party responsibility is still very low. They're the easiest role to play. 2. Yanxian. • 4 yr. ago. I'd say give ranged dps a try, they don't have the movement restrictions that melee and casters do. 1. [deleted]If you don't mind turretting in one place for big numbers, try black mage. 5. Drekor. • 2 yr. ago. SMN - Easiest of the classes by far. Has a great deal of mobility and barely has to stop and cast at all. Has a res so is also quite useful to a group. RDM - Probably the most well rounded caster.So, overall, every class is easy and every class is hard on its own way, so try and choose what you like more. Reply reply [deleted] • Black Mage is without a doubt the most difficult to play. ... A community for fans of the critically acclaimed MMORPG Final Fantasy XIV, with an expanded free trial that includes the entirety of A Realm Reborn ...If you're looking for something with sustain you're looking at a tank, rdm, or a healer. I find any ranged class to be fun for solo stuff outside of dungeons. Bard and machinist are fun because most of their abilities are instant so you can move around while you kill things. The machinist class quests are also decent.The Warrior is a solid go-to option for any FF XIV player keen on testing their talents of leading a dungeon. While it is the easiest, you'll have to master the finer points of this class.As the 6.4 patch of FFXIV is coming, I want to recommend these 5 easiest and most braindead classes for savage raiding to newer players who wanted to try out...Feb 17, 2023 ... Comments217 ; Why Tenacity is a TERRIBLE stat in FFXIV! Caetsu Chaiji Ch. · 38K views ; FFXIV Tank Comparison! Easy/Hard? Strong/Weak? Intense?Samurai is a FFXIV Job that's easy to play, but hard to play well. You don't have any utility, but buffs from other classes can help you out a lot. However, your rotation requires some set-up before your burst window, and if that preparation is interrupted by something like a death, you'll have a tough time recovering.Square Enix. Final Fantasy 14 is one of the best MMOs around, and new players are still pouring in a decade after launch. Here's a beginner's guide to FF14 classes. ….

Red Mage has less oGCDs and CPM in general, and it's a pretty easy and straightforward job. Summoner is much more complicated, but should be easier to raid with than BLM and has a comparable CPM to Red Mage. MCH has an unusually high CPM though, so you might be able to bear with many of the other dps jobs as well.The following FF14 jobs classes tier list is a curated guide that reflects the current meta of FFXIV, offering insights into which classes and jobs excel in various …His primary game beats are Pokémon Go, Destiny 2, Final Fantasy XIV, and any newly released title, and he finds it difficult to pull away from any Star Wars game. Gamepur Logo Putting the game in ...There's a good reason there are a huge amount more clears on MCH as opposed to RDM. The top 3 easiest classes to do POTD solo with are MCH > RDM > NIN. (NIN has to be seen to be believed, it has a really unique kit that allows it to do things other classes can't) 6. UnlikelyTraditions.Oct 14, 2023 · Healers in FFXIV occupy a role which makes them a bit more complicated to balance than other classes. What makes a healer good in prog may not necessarily make them good for maximizing DPS. In addition, there is the split of regen versus shield healers, often referred to as "pure healers" and "barrier healers" respectively. A community for fans of the critically acclaimed MMORPG Final Fantasy XIV, with an expanded free trial that includes the entirety of A Realm Reborn and the award-winning Heavensward and Stormblood expansions up to level 70 with no restrictions on playtime. ... Dancer is the easiest out of the physical ranged classes, samurai for the melees ... At the start of the game these are the base classes that are pretty simple and easy to use by the time you get to lvl 90. The rotations are straightforward/static and easy to learn. Later on you class upgrades to a job. Tank -Marauder/Warrior. Healer - Conjurer/White mage. Dps - Arcanist/Summoner, Lancer/Dragoon. discord: https://discord.gg/HQNkbqvNdchttps://www.twitch.tv/kougaon_https://twitter.com/Kougaon_Thank you to https://twitter.com/ryumaxx_ for art!Music that ...The Basics Of Class-Ranking. #4 - Scholar. #3 - White Mage. #2 - Sage. #1 - Astrologian. General Tips. Final Fantasy 14 's healer class options were limited to three for a long time — too long, some would argue. That all changed with the arrival of Endwalker late last year, and the introduction of the Sage. Now there's a whole quartet of ... Ffxiv easiest classes, FFXIV's latest expansion, Endwalker, is out now! Members Online • Please_Wave ... It really comes down to knowing your class. WHM is the easiest to understand but I have been playing Astro so much I can heal with astro easier than I can heal with WHM. WHM is a good entry level healer though and gets the basics down but it is worth trying the ..., Tank Tier List. Tier lists in Final Fantasy XIV should be taken with a grain of salt, as the better player will almost always out-perform the worse player, regardless of the chosen job. As of patch 6.4, all four tanks are quite well balanced, each bringing adequate utility and similar damage into raids. Some types of content may slightly prefer ..., Starting out her only options will be Archer, Thramaturge, and Arcanist. Of those I would say Archer is the easiest, but Arcanist opens up into both Summoner and Scholar that level at the same rate. It's nice if she wanted to try healing later on without having to level a second class. 4. JadedRoll. , Gunbreaker, Warrior, White mage, Scholar, Sage, Dragoon, Reaper, Ranged Dps, Summoner, all have pretty simple rotation and are more or less easy to optimize. Summoner, you don't even have to think about RNG which the DNC has to. Depending on the role you want to play, but as a main White mage/monk, I can recommend you white mage., Nin is slower in it's down time, but it's burst phase is faster than Mnks. Drg and Sam were equal for me as well. Both require some braincells to use, but nothing major. Rpr is by far the easiest and flows together well. Final order is Nin=Mnk>Drg=Sam>Rpr. Phys Ranged- All fairly easy to pick up., There are four types of tanks in Final Fantasy XIV: Warrior, Dark Knight, Gunbreaker, and Paladin. FFXIV Tank Job - Warrior. Warrior's base class is Marauder and uses a Two-handed Axe. According to an online vote, it's the most played tank in Final Fantasy XIV. In battles, Warrior uses basic combo abilities to gain Beast Gauge., In fact, you will first need to reach level 10 with your first combat class and complete the class quest for the same. level. Once this step is reached you can change class as you see fit, provided you have unlocked more than one class. To change classes, you only have to equip the primary weapon of the class you want to take., One of the most popular uses for crafting is to make Gil. This might be to buy a house and furnishings, a few cosmetics, gear your classes or to simply stockpile hundreds of millions to use in the future or even just for the sake of it. Crafting is one of the best methods for this, with a large range of Gil making methods across all level ranges., Healer damage matters a lot. 18. madorily. • 4 yr. ago. WHM is the easiest healer. It has extremely high personal damage output and its healing is pretty straight forward. But I think SCH would prepare you better for healing. It's the medium difficulty healer in my opinion, but it has some key things that WHM just doesn't have, or has little ..., Producing pure destructive force, the Black Mage is a powerhouse of damage, holding one of the highest personal DPS stats in the game. Black Mage Class Pros: Very high single-target damage. Strong AoE damage. Easy to learn, with a well-paced rotation flow. Easily managed and replenished MP pool., With the flexibility FFXIV affords its players, you're free to try on as many different play styles as you'd like to determine which class you prefer—and consequently, which jobs you're likely to enjoy taking on.Jobs are the specialized versions of their respective starting classes, and you'll be expected to perform whichever role you assume dutifully so that your party can clear dungeons ..., Nov 29, 2023 · 1. ARCANIST/SUMMONER. The Summoner branch of the Arcanist has become the easiest Job to play in the game. Though the Summoner used to be much more complicated with a lot more to pay attention to, it’s over-simplified now and offers a great amount of friendliness to beginners. , If you're looking for something with sustain you're looking at a tank, rdm, or a healer. I find any ranged class to be fun for solo stuff outside of dungeons. Bard and machinist are fun because most of their abilities are instant so you can move around while you kill things. The machinist class quests are also decent., Once you start running dungeons, having a healer or tank class will make it so you can queue much fast (sub 5 mins vs 15-20 at times for DPS). It won't be hard to level 2 or even 3 at the same time. Make sure you are enjoying the class. Remember FFXIV is a game where one character can be literally every class., Healers Easy- WHM Hard- SCH. Melee Easy- RPR Hard- MNK. Phys ranged Easy- DNC Hard- MCH. Casters Easy- SMN Hard- BLM. This is all my opinion but I would say black mage is probably the hardest in the game just because of how it plays and knowing fights helps it more than any other class. [deleted] • 2 yr. ago., PLD has the easiest rotations imho. Fast blade > Savage Blade > Rage of Halone is aggrobuilder Fast Blade > Riot Blade > (dunno the names)Damage Dealing Fast Blade > Riot Blade > DoT applying attack. The last two are only after Lv 50; you'll be using 1 2 3 pretty much the whole time. Reply reply., FFXIV Class Guide — DPS Classes. DPS Classes/Jobs make up the lion's share of a group's damage output. They offset this massive damage potential by being some of the squishier classes in the game — maybe not as bad as Healers, but you still need to be careful. And every second spent healing a DPS player is a second spent not healing a Tank., A community for fans of the critically acclaimed MMORPG Final Fantasy XIV, with an expanded free trial that includes the entirety of A Realm Reborn and the award-winning Heavensward and Stormblood expansions up to level 70 with no restrictions on playtime. ... WHM is widely regarded in the game as the easiest healer class. SCH or AST are ..., If you want to know more about Performance to Skill Ratioson all jobs, or other Differences, check out these videosCasual Tier List: https://youtu.be/rT5rKMP..., The BRD rotation is easy, but the class has a gajillion buttons. ... A community for fans of the critically acclaimed MMORPG Final Fantasy XIV, with an expanded free trial that includes the entirety of A Realm Reborn and the award-winning Heavensward and Stormblood expansions up to level 70 with no restrictions on playtime. FFXIV's latest ..., FFXIV has been, first and foremost, a PvE game.While this MMO has some PvP content that has improved recently, people still prefer the intricate dungeons and raids. However, every PvP season brings some fantastic rewards, including some of the game’s best cosmetics, hence why many are jumping into some player-versus-player action.If …, This FFXIV leveling guide is all about reaching the level cap of 90 in Final Fantasy 14 fast. It can be a slow process but there are lots of ways to make the journey much faster., BLM has a really simple rotation, but you do have to worry about movement (or more making sure you never have to move). Each class and job can be played to several levels. If you're a top level raider you're going to squeeze every bit of uptime into your rotations as possible., So what are the easiest & best classes to start out with in final fantasy xiv? If you're a new player this guide can give you some ideas on what class to pic..., Quite a few of my viewers were surprised that the GC Squadron was an actual feature in the game when I mentioned it in my original powerleveling guide, and a..., So what are the easiest & best classes to start out with in final fantasy xiv? If you're a new player this guide can give you some ideas on what class to pic..., These are spread throughout the world, and some have specific level requirements. This guide will detail every way to unlock the classes in Final Fantasy 14. Updated December 24, 2023: We've updated this article to make sure the information presented below is clear, easy to understand, and helpful. Later in 2024, we'll have all the information ..., As the 6.4 patch of FFXIV is coming, I want to recommend these 5 easiest and most braindead classes for savage raiding to newer players who wanted to try out..., FFXIV's latest expansion, Endwalker, is out now! ... Its easy to pull your weight with these classes. I do not recommend healing job tho if you want something easy. Healer skill floor is low but skill ceiling is very high and if you wanna pull weight as a healer, you gotta know a lot of nuances, and able to make good judgement in high pressure ..., If you want to know more about Performance to Skill Ratioson all jobs, or other Differences, check out these videosCasual Tier List: https://youtu.be/rT5rKMP..., DNC -> Very intuitive, very mobile, and a lot of glowey buttons - I'd say Dancer is probably the easiest class in the game to just play at a good level quickly. Optimizing it can actually be a bit tricky, but even still, I'd say Dancer is on the whole the simplest class in the game to play. RDM -> Easiest caster. , 5. Black Mage. A Black Mage who wields powerful spells capable of flattening the terrain. The first job on this list is a Black Mage, which is ideal for gamers that enjoy playing as a Mage or a Caster, wielding powerful spells and casting their ultimate assaults., I haven’t had much experience in MMOs really since FFXI and ESO on my Xbox a little bit. So I was curious what everyone thinks is the most straight forward and easiest classes to start with and even master. So I guess my question is which class/jobs are the easiest in each role of tank, healer, ranged dps and dps?